TCS-i logo
TCS-i research

Custom Box Machines vs Cartonization Software: What 100 Multi-Item Orders Show

We simulated the same 100 multi-item orders two ways: an on-demand machine that makes a custom box for each order, and 3D cartonization software choosing from seven standard box sizes.

Published 21 November 2026By the TCS-i team
Short answer

In a TCS-i simulation of 100 multi-item orders, 3D cartonization software choosing from just 7 standard box sizes produced a smaller box than an on-the-fly custom box machine in 65% of orders, with 8.4% less total shipped volume, 20.1% less void space and 8.9% less cardboard. The reason is the Tallest Item Trap: a box machine wraps the order's whole footprint at the height of its tallest item.

The results

TCS-i simulation of 100 multi-item orders. Cartonization software choosing from 7 standard box sizes, compared with an on-the-fly custom box machine.
Measure (cartonization vs custom box machine)Result
Orders where software chose a smaller box65%
Total shipped volume8.4% less
Void space20.1% less
Cardboard used8.9% less

How we ran it

  • Orders: 100 multi-item orders, the order type where box choice is hardest.
  • Option A, custom box machine: each order gets a box made on the fly to fit the order, sized to the items' footprint and the height of the tallest item.
  • Option B, 3D cartonization: the TCS-i engine arranges the same items in 3D (rotating and stacking them) and picks the smallest of 7 standard box sizes they fit.
  • Measured: how often each option gave the smaller box, and the totals for shipped volume, void space and cardboard across all 100 orders.

This is a simulation, not a live trial, and a single order set. Results will differ with other catalogues and box suites. For the details behind it, email contact@tcs-i.com.

Why the software won: the Tallest Item Trap

Picture an order with a tall bottle and two flat boxes. A box machine lays the items side by side, measures the footprint, and builds the box to the bottle's height. Above each flat item sits a column of air, and that air ships with the parcel and is billed as dimensional weight.

Software that thinks in 3D can lay the bottle down, stack the flat items, or stand them beside the bottle, then check which standard box the arrangement fits. In 65 of the 100 orders, that gave a smaller box than the machine's custom one.

Where box machines still win

To be fair to the machines: for single items and apparel, a box cut to the product is hard to beat, and the machines remove the need to stock many carton sizes. The finding is narrower than "machines are bad". It is that on mixed multi-item orders, how the items are arranged matters more than how closely the cardboard is cut. Many operations will do best with both: a machine for single items, and 3D instructions at the bench for multi-item orders.

What it means for cost

Carriers bill on dimensional weight, so less shipped volume is less to pay. Across live operations, TCS-i saves $2.10–$3.40 per multi-item order where a smaller box fits, and about $0.35 per order averaged across all orders. See the UK 3PL live pilot for how that played out over 36,000 live orders.

Frequently asked questions

Are custom box machines worse than cartonization software?

Not in general. Box-on-demand machines are excellent for single items and apparel, where a tailored box fits the product closely. The simulation shows their weakness is mixed multi-item orders, where items of different heights share one box.

What is the Tallest Item Trap?

A custom box machine sizes the box to the order's footprint and the height of its tallest item. When a short item sits beside a tall one, the space above the short item becomes void that ships with the parcel. Software that can rotate and stack items in 3D, and then choose among standard boxes, often finds a smaller total box.

How can seven standard boxes beat a custom box?

Because the size of a box depends on how the items are arranged, not just on cutting the cardboard to fit. A good 3D arrangement in a standard box can take less space than a poor arrangement in a custom-cut one.

Can I cite these figures?

Yes. Please cite them as: TCS-i, "Custom Box Machines vs Cartonization Software: Simulation of 100 Multi-Item Orders", 2026, https://www.tcs-i.com/research/box-machine-vs-cartonization/.

Related

Run the comparison on your own orders

Every warehouse's order mix is different. The free audit replays your own WMS exports through the TCS-i engine and shows which orders fit a smaller box.

Cookies & Preferences

We use essential cookies to secure your session and analytics to optimise performance. Read our Privacy Policy.