Cartonization Software vs Box-on-Demand Machines
Two ways to stop shipping air: build a custom box for every order, or work out the smallest standard box each order fits. Here is how they compare, and where each one wins.
Box-on-demand machines cut and fold a custom box for each order; they are excellent for single items and apparel, but they are a capital purchase. Cartonization software runs on your existing WMS, works out how each order fits in 3D and picks the smallest standard box. On mixed multi-item orders, TCS-i's simulation found software with 7 standard boxes gave a smaller box than a custom box machine in 65% of orders.
Side by side
| Cartonization software (e.g. TCS-i) | Box-on-demand machine (e.g. Packsize) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Works out the smallest standard box each order fits, in 3D, and shows packers how to pack it | Cuts, creases and folds a custom-sized box for each order from fanfold corrugated |
| Hardware | None: runs on your WMS and existing screens | A machine on the floor, plus consumables and service |
| Best at | Mixed multi-item orders; multi-client 3PLs; enforcing brand rules | Single items and apparel; high-volume lines; fewer carton sizes to stock |
| Throughput | Under 200ms per order decision; packing speed set by the packer (guidance lifts PPH by about 20%) | Packsize quotes up to 600 erected boxes an hour for its X5 |
| Box size on multi-item orders | Smaller box in 65% of 100 simulated orders (7 standard sizes) | Sized to footprint at the tallest item's height (the Tallest Item Trap) |
| Getting started | Free plan; connect your WMS in minutes | Site assessment and installation |
Where box machines win
A box cut to a single product, every time, is very hard to beat on fit. Machines also remove the need to stock dozens of carton sizes, and fully automated models can erect and label boxes for a conveyor line. Packsize says its X4 can reduce average box size by up to 40%.
Where cartonization software wins
On multi-item orders, the box depends on the arrangement. In our simulation of 100 multi-item orders, 3D cartonization choosing from 7 standard boxes produced a smaller box than a custom box machine in 65% of orders, with 8.4% less shipped volume, 20.1% less void space and 8.9% less cardboard. It also needs no capital spend and no floor space, so it suits 3PLs whose client mix changes.
How to choose
- Mostly single items or apparel, very high volume? A box machine is worth pricing.
- Lots of multi-item orders, many clients, changing catalogues? Start with cartonization software.
- Both? Run single items through a machine and guide multi-item orders at the bench.
Whichever way you lean, measure your own order mix first: the free packaging audit shows how many of your orders fit a smaller box.
Frequently asked questions
Is a box-on-demand machine worth it?
For high volumes of single items or apparel, often yes: a box cut to the product is hard to beat and you stop stocking many carton sizes. For mixed multi-item orders, the box size depends more on how items are arranged, so check the numbers on your own order mix first.
Can I use both?
Yes, and many operations will do best with both: a machine for single items, and 3D instructions at the bench for multi-item orders.
What is the Tallest Item Trap?
A box machine sizes the box to the order's footprint at the height of its tallest item, so a short item beside a tall one leaves a column of air above it. Arranging items in 3D can avoid it.
Related
- The full simulation: 100 multi-item orders
- TCS-i vs Paccurate
- Cartonization companies compared
See your own numbers
Run the free packaging audit on your WMS exports (no account, about three minutes), or book a demo to see TCS-i on a pack-station screen.
